Live Webinar and Q&A – The Login Experience Customers Want (Live Webinar Sept 9th, 2021) Save Your Seat
Facilitating the spread of knowledge and innovation in professional software development

The Excel team announced LAMBDA, a new feature that lets users define and name formula functions. LAMBDA functions admit parameters, can call other LAMBDA functions and recursively call themselves. With LAMBDA, the Excel formula language is Turing-complete: user-defined functions can thus compute anything without resorting to imperative languages (e.g., VBA, JavaScript).
In this episode of the InfoQ podcast Charles Humble talks to Lucas Cavalcanti about Nubank’s early architectural choices, including starting with Clojure and microservices. They discuss the challenges of using public cloud for financial services in Brazil, Nubank’s use of Alistair Cockburn’s Hexagonal Architecture and immutable architecture, and lessons learnt as the startup scaled.
How AI, ML and Data Engineering are evolving in 2021 as seen by the InfoQ editorial team. Topics discussed include deep learning, edge deployment of machine learning algorithms, commercial robot platforms, GPU and CUDA programming, natural language processing and GPT-3, MLOps, and AutoML.
Change in most organizations today seems to be locked in the paradigm of yesterday’s logic – repeating the same top-down, command driven approaches that consistently fail to achieve the expected benefits. The environment today requires new approaches drawing on concepts from modern management approaches. This article introduces a number of ideas and approaches to break out of the old paradigm.
Michael Hausenblas discusses good practices and current developments around CNCF open source projects and specifications including OpenTelemetry and FluentBit.
Learn how to apply containerized applications to improve application speed, reliability and deployment. Virtual Event on September 21th, 9AM EDT / 3PM CEST
Learn how to apply Microservices and DevSecOps to improve application security & deployment speed. Virtual Event on Oct 19th, 9AM EDT/ 3PM CEST
Learn from world-class domain experts. Attend online on Nov 1-12.
InfoQ Homepage Articles Low-Code Platforms and the Rise of the Community Developer: Lots of Solutions, or Lots of Problems?
This item in japanese
Feb 02, 2021 12 min read
Doug Hudgeon
reviewed by
Daniel Bryant
Low-code platforms are the hottest enterprise software category right now. In addition to hundreds of startups, over the past 24 months, each of the big three cloud providers has launched its own low-code platform. With this level of investment, it’s hard to imagine a future that doesn’t feature lots of bespoke business apps being built by non-IT staff for use by their teams. 

To help you understand how this trend will impact your IT organization, we discuss the types of low-code platforms available and the type of staff in your organization who will be attracted to them. We then look at how low-code platforms fit into your IT architecture and, finally, provide our views on optimal strategies for managing IT in a low-code world.
Uncover emerging trends and practices from the world’s most innovative software professionals. Attend QCon Plus (November, 2021).
You can think of low-code platforms like you think of Excel. They are just software tools in the hands of your users that are useful in a wide variety of business scenarios. With these tools, they can create solutions or problems. 
We group low-code platforms into three different categories. Each category will attract a different type of user in your organization. 
Click here to view a sortable list of low code platforms.
Community developers are staff in your organization who use low-code platforms to create solutions for themselves and their teams that solve a particular business problem.
These users have always existed. Today, you can see them creating masterpieces in Excel. Excel users can be grouped into the same categories we use for low-code platforms.
Most community developers will progress through three stages as they become more capable of using the low-code platform. Many community developers won’t progress beyond the first or second stage but some will go onto the third stage and build full-featured applications used throughout your business.
Stage 1—UI Generation: Initially they will create applications with nice user interfaces with data that is keyed into the application. For example, they may make a meeting notes application that allows users to jointly add meeting notes as a meeting progresses. This is the UI Generation stage.
Stage 2—Integration: As users gain experience, they’ll move to the second stage where they start pulling in data from external systems and data sources. For example, they’ll enhance their meeting notes application to pull calendar information from Outlook and email attendees after each meeting with a copy of the notes. This is the Integration stage. 
Stage 3—Transformation: And, finally, they’ll start creating applications that perform increasingly sophisticated transformations. For example, they may run the meeting notes through a machine learning model to tag and store the meeting content so that it can be searched by topic. This is the Transformation stage.
Community developers are building low-code applications because they aren’t able to use your enterprise systems to accomplish certain tasks. You can think of your enterprise system stack as a mosaic. Your goal is to make your application stack look like a well-tiled wall with each application connected directly to adjacent applications.

Photo by Wengang Zhai on Unsplash
But the reality is that mergers, acquisitions, historical anomalies, and changing business requirements mean your stack overlaps in some areas and has gaps in other areas. It’s these gaps that drive community developers to create Excel spreadsheets or use low-code platforms to fill the gaps. Your users may view your IT stack more like the image below than the image above.

Photo by Марьян Блан | @marjanblan on Unsplash
To assist these users, you historically have had three options to plug gaps in your stack:
Each of these options has pros and cons. 
The first option (enhancing your core systems) allows your development team to provide a solution that addresses the users’ needs without adding additional systems or apps to your stack. The downside is that these solutions take time to build, test, and deploy and you are limited by the resources available on your team. It doesn’t take long for demand to outstrip your ability to provide custom solutions. 
The second option (building a bespoke solution) is often easier than enhancing your ERP system but still requires significant effort on your part to develop, test, deploy, and support the solution.
The third option (using a third-party solution) can result in a very full-featured solution but it takes time and resources to procure and integrate. And quite often the third-party solutions include features that overlap with your other enterprise systems leading to multiple ways for your users to accomplish the same task.
Community developers provide you with a fourth option to fill the gaps in your IT capability. Theoretically, your organization’s IT capability should be dramatically increased if you have a small army of community developers building applications that scratch their team’s itch. 
But the risks are also substantial. Picture your IT team as a small group of wizards who perform magic to help your kingdom. Now imagine the change to your society if suddenly everyone could perform magic. Great things could be accomplished but mistakes would inevitably occur and you might find that someone has inadvertently exposed to neighboring kingdoms the plans to your castle’s defenses.
Community developers create two types of risks. We’ll discuss these risks using examples where Excel use has created a problem.
Click here to see more examples of Excel risks. Reading through these will help drive home the types of risks your community developers will expose you to.
Each stage of low-code usage has a different risk profile for your organization. 
Stage 1 (UI Generation) community developers are low risk. The data they work with is typically manually entered into the application, e.g., the meeting notes application discussed above. You should manage this in the same way that you handle acceptable use for email and other forms of communication. 
Stage 2 (Integration) community developers are higher risk. They are using low-code platforms to read and write data to systems such as your CRM (Customer Relationship Management) system or external APIs such as Clearbit for enhancing prospect data or Mailgun for sending bulk emails. These types of applications perform functions such as providing field staff with job data taken from your support system or provide sales staff with information extracted from your CRM. These applications introduce user authentication risks as well as data security issues. You’ll want to place appropriate controls on what systems users integrate with and what is done with the data. 
Stage 3 (Transformation) community developers are the highest risk category. In addition to reading and writing to your systems and from external systems, they are also transforming data. These types of applications include apps that draw on machine learning solutions such as AWS Sagemaker to deliver unique benefits to your organization. For example, a Stage 3 Community Developer may take prospect data from your CRM, combine it with data extracted from Twitter, run a topic model analysis through AWS Sagemaker, and use it to target prospects based on the topics they are tweeting about. 
In addition to the risks introduced in the integration phase, these applications also carry the risk of incorrectly transforming data. For example, if the Community Developer built a machine learning model that classified the severity of a customer support issue (and therefore the priority in which it’s handled) you don’t want their model to have a gender or racial bias that results in your organization improperly favoring one group of customers over another.
The diagrams below show how we think about risk in low-code platform usage.
Each diagram represents a stage. The orange-colored section of each stage is the proportion of apps that the IT organization shouldn’t get involved with. The purple and red colored sections of each stage show the proportion of apps the IT organization should get involved with. The red-colored section shows the proportion of apps that deal with sensitive data where there is an integration risk. The purple section shows the proportion of apps where the complexity of the app is high enough to warrant involvement from the IT team.
The first diagram shows category 1, UI Generation apps. Most of these applications are low risk and IT only needs to get involved when the type of data in the application requires some controls placed over it. For example, you wouldn’t get involved with a meeting notes app but you would get involved with a patient notes app. Only rarely would these apps be complex enough to warrant IT involvement.

The next diagram shows category 2 apps that integrate with other systems. This category contains potentially riskier applications. IT should be involved with a greater proportion of these than the stage 1 applications as indicated by the larger purple area and red areas and smaller orange area.

The final diagram shows category 3 apps that involve significant data transformation functions. This category contains the riskiest applications. IT should be involved with a greater proportion of these than stage 2 applications as indicated by the large purple area and small orange area.

Like it or not, community developers are already in your organization using Excel and they are about to start demanding access to the new breed of low-code platforms. We see this trend as unstoppable. You can fight against it, or you can accept the inevitable and embrace it. Done right, having a small army of community developers in your organization can dramatically enhance your IT capability.
Today, most organizations are exposed to material risks from the vast number of spreadsheets used by decision-makers to make business decisions. If low-code platforms start replacing some of these spreadsheets, then the spread of low-code platforms through your organization can lower the overall IT risk in your company.
Maximizing the visibility of low-code solutions is the key to managing risk. To maximize the visibility inherent in having community developers building apps, we recommend you make available a single low-code platform for your community developers. 
Which low-code solution should you adopt? It probably doesn’t matter much. We see the feature sets of low-code platforms becoming largely undifferentiated—there’s only so many things a low-code platform can do and the level of investment in the space means that they’ll all be able to do these things. So, if you don’t have a preferred low-code platform in mind, just use the one provided by your cloud provider. If you are a Microsoft Azure customer, use Power Apps. If you are an AWS customer, use Honeycode. And if you are a Google customer, use Appsheet. 
Next, make training available to your community developers on that platform. Once they are comfortable using a particular platform they are much less likely to demand access to a different one. As long as you provide an outlet for your users to scratch their low-code itch, they will be able to accomplish what they want to accomplish.
And, finally, develop some expertise in your team on the machine learning and data transformation services offered by your existing IT stack/cloud provider. When your community developers need access to a machine learning platform they may as well use one you already have access to so you can more easily control your data.
Doug Hudgeon is the co-author of the Manning book Machine Learning for Business which shows your users how to solve real-world business problems using AWS SageMaker. InfoQ can get this book for 50% off using the code hudgeonpc. He is also the chief executive officer of Managed Functions a company on a mission to interconnect every business application with actionable data. Once a business process becomes too complex or too risky for a community developer, you can refer your community developers to Managed Functions who assess the risk levels of the low-code application and, where the risk is beyond a certain threshold, build and maintain the integration/transformation component of the app. And, uniquely, deploy the component as a cloud-native function on your AWS, Azure, or Google cloud so your data stays in your environment.

A round-up of last week’s content on InfoQ sent out every Tuesday. Join a community of over 250,000 senior developers. View an example

We protect your privacy.
You need to Register an InfoQ account or or login to post comments. But there’s so much more behind being registered.
Get the most out of the InfoQ experience.
Allowed html: a,b,br,blockquote,i,li,pre,u,ul,p
by Paulo Morgado,
by Doug Hudgeon,
by Rob Kraft,
by Paulo Morgado,
Your message is awaiting moderation. Thank you for participating in the discussion.
by Doug Hudgeon,
Your message is awaiting moderation. Thank you for participating in the discussion.
Hi Paulo, I have. It’s an impressive application. In hindsight, it would have been good to include it in those listed 🙂
by Rob Kraft,
Your message is awaiting moderation. Thank you for participating in the discussion.
Business and Product Owners can benefit greatly from learning about the existence of such tools. Too many currently rely, and wait, on their IT departments to help them solve business problems unaware that they could solve many problems more quickly, and with less cost, than waiting on their IT departments.
And IT departments need to learn these tools also because they could deliver solutions faster also in many cases instead of spending the time to build and deploy all the components using the methods they have learned over the last decade.

Allowed html: a,b,br,blockquote,i,li,pre,u,ul,p

Allowed html: a,b,br,blockquote,i,li,pre,u,ul,p

A round-up of last week’s content on InfoQ sent out every Tuesday. Join a community of over 250,000 senior developers. View an example

We protect your privacy.
Focus on the topics that matter in software development right now.
Deep-dive with 64+ world-class software leaders. Discover how they are applying emerging trends. Learn their use cases and best practices.
Stay ahead of the adoption curve and shape your roadmap with QCon Plus online software development conference. and all content copyright © 2006-2021 C4Media Inc. hosted at Contegix, the best ISP we’ve ever worked with.
Privacy Notice, Terms And Conditions, Cookie Policy
Is your profile up-to-date? Please take a moment to review and update.
Note: If updating/changing your email, a validation request will be sent


Leave a Reply